0100,0100,0100I am grateful to Doug. Henderson of the National Marine
Aquarium for the following information on the Balance
Fish/Hammerhead Shark.
"The species (of Hammerhead) most likely to be seen is
Sphyrna zygaena, which occasionally occurs in northern
European waters. Wheeler (1978) says "recorded 5 times in
the present century in northern European waters, and at least
7 times in the 19thC". I can find no reference to any further
North than South Wales. Hence while a sighting (in Scotland)
is feasible, it is pretty unlikely".
To reurn to Sid's point, it looks as though out of the 29
species of sharks recorded in UK waters, Verne chose the
least likely one to be found in the Clyde.
Nejat makes the perfectly valid point that Verne was writing
fiction, not factual accounts and obviously the vast majority of
readers appreciate his novels as such. However, I do believe
there is some merit in exploring the factual basis of his novels if
only to further admire the man's genius. For example, we
know that he was producing at least two novels a year and
that each manuscript went through substantial revisions. It is
remarkable that he found the time, energy and resources to
research the factual background so thoroughly and for the
most part accurately in relation to the state of knowledge at
the time. For example, I have researched the local detail of the
5 novels involving Glasgow and have found him correct in
virtually all respects, including things that I didn't know myself
in spite of 28 years of residence here!.I find that it is the blend
of fact and fiction that for me is the fascination of Verne, but
of course the value of the fiction must always predominate.
Ian Thompson