0100,0100,0100Garmt doubts whether anyone could read the entire Verne's
"Géographie" without falling asleep. Before complaining too
much about the aridity of the work I think it is important to
remember the context of its publication.
1. The work was commenced by Théophile Lavallée who
wrote the general section and on his death Verne was
commissioned to write the sections on each département. To
some extent therefore, the nature of the work had been
determined before Verne became involved.
2. More importantly, Verne was following the method and
status of geography in the mid-nineteenth century in France. In
the national curriculum geography was linked with history and
teachers were trained to teach both subjects but most often
were more interested and competent in history than geography
, which often, and until quite recently, was poorly taught.This
was especially true of the scientific aspects of geography. It
was often seen as subsidiary to history with relevance as a
background to historic events rather than a discipline in its
own right. It was not until Paul Vidal de la Blache, towards
the end of the nineteenth century, Professor of Geography at
the Ecole Normale and then the Sorbonne, developed a form
of geography stressing man's dynamic relationship to the
environment that geography became an intellectual discipline in
its own right and broke away from a descriptive and inventory
approach.Even the distinguished Paganel, in Les Enfants du
Capitaine Grant, is an armchair geographer, full of esoteric
book knowledge. To that extent therefore Verne was
following the paradigm of the time in his approach in "La
Géographie". Conversely, his novels gave him the chance to
break away from fossilised fact and even though much of his
geography remains descriptive, its imbrication within a plot
brings it to life. Moreover, publication in serial form in
magazines made his work accessible to youth at a time when
competition from other media forms hardly existed and thus
helped to pupularise geography. In short, "La Géographie"
responded to the didactic needs of the time and was not
intended as literature. However, his mastery of geographical
fact and processes gave Verne a solid base on which to
weave his adventures and justifies his claim to be the inventor
(in France at least) of the "geographical novel"
Ian Thompson.